Tragedy of the commons

From Liberpedia

The tragedy of the commons can arise when users gain from taking more of a shared, exhaustible resource while bearing only part of the cost that their use imposes on others.[1]

The pasture argument

Garrett Hardin illustrated the problem with a pasture open to everyone. A herder receives the proceeds from adding another animal, but the resulting overgrazing affects all the herders. The private gain can therefore encourage each to expand the herd even when their combined grazing damages the resource. The conflict concerns the incentives created by unrestricted use; it does not require users to intend the eventual damage.[1]

Hardin's 1968 essay used this argument to advocate restrictions on population growth. For other resource problems, he discussed private property, regulation and taxation. His essay's political programme thus extended beyond the pasture example.[1]

Open access and governed commons

Brett Frischmann, Alain Marciano and Giovanni Battista Ramello identify two distinctions obscured by Hardin's argument: the characteristics of a resource differ from the institutions governing it, and open access differs from community-governed common property. A group can share a resource while restricting membership, agreeing on harvesting rules and enforcing those rules.[2]

They connect this criticism to Elinor Ostrom's research on users who communicate and devise institutions. Such arrangements sometimes succeed and sometimes fail. A prediction made with fixed rules and independent decisions does not establish what happens when users can change those rules or cooperate.[2]

The same distinction matters for knowledge. Copying an idea does not consume it as harvesting removes fish. The difficulty of financing its creation differs from the overuse of a rival resource; applying one label to both can conceal different problems.[2]

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Garrett Hardin, “The Tragedy of the Commons”, Science 162(3859), 13 December 1968, pp. 1243–1248; university-hosted published paper.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 Brett M. Frischmann, Alain Marciano and Giovanni Battista Ramello, “Retrospectives: Tragedy of the Commons after 50 Years”, Journal of Economic Perspectives 33(4), Fall 2019, pp. 211–228, especially pp. 218–224; university repository.