Prestige bias

From Liberpedia

Prestige bias is a tendency to learn from people who receive other people's attention or freely given deference. It differs from judging someone's competence directly, or selecting them by signs of success such as wealth.[1]

Joseph Henrich and Francisco Gil-White propose that deference can help learners obtain access to skilled people and their knowledge. Observing who already receives deference can reduce the cost of choosing whom to learn from. Learners may subsequently revise that choice through experience. The theory also allows irrelevant or harmful traits to spread alongside useful ones when people copy a successful person's broader behaviour.[2]

Prestige and dominance

Henrich and Gil-White distinguish prestige from compliance obtained through force or threatened costs. Their distinction concerns processes: the same person can be admired for expertise and also exercise coercive authority. Institutional positions can combine both. Receiving deference therefore does not, by itself, show which process produced it.[2]

Evidence from children

Chudek and colleagues showed children videos in which bystanders watched one adult and ignored another, without demonstrating superior competence. In their second study, involving 48 children, the attention cue influenced subsequent learning more strongly within the same domain—artifact use or food preferences. The estimated probability of copying the attended adult was about 69% on tests in the same domain and 52% in the other. Differences on individual tasks were not consistently statistically clear.[1]

The experiment simultaneously directed attention towards one adult and away from the other, so it did not separate those influences. The authors explicitly state that the findings alone do not establish that ancestral selection produced prestige-biased learning. The learning effect, its cognitive mechanism and its evolutionary origin remain distinct questions.[1]

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 Maciej Chudek, Sarah Heller, Susan Birch and Joseph Henrich, “Prestige-biased cultural learning: bystander's differential attention to potential models influences children's learning”, Evolution and Human Behavior 33(1), 2012, pp. 46–56, especially pp. 47–48, 50–54.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 Joseph Henrich and Francisco J. Gil-White, “The evolution of prestige: Freely conferred deference as a mechanism for enhancing the benefits of cultural transmission”, Evolution and Human Behavior 22(3), 2001, pp. 165–196, especially pp. 170–179 and 184–187.