Overconfidence

From Liberpedia

Overconfidence concerns confidence that exceeds what performance or evidence warrants. Don Moore and Paul Healy distinguish errors about one's result, relative standing and certainty.[1]

Three measures

Measure Error Hypothetical illustration
Overestimation Overstating one's actual performance Expecting 8 correct answers but getting 5.
Overplacement Overstating one's position relative to others Expecting to lead another person by 3 points but finishing 1 point behind.
Overprecision Expressing excessive certainty Giving ranges with stated 90% probability that contain the result only 60% of the time across repeated judgments.

These are different comparisons. Someone can underestimate a score while overestimating relative standing.[1]

Task difficulty and information

Moore and Healy studied 82 participants taking eighteen ten-question quizzes. On easy quizzes, participants underestimated their scores but overplaced themselves relative to another participant; difficult quizzes produced the reverse pattern on average.[1]

Their model explains this pattern through imperfect information about one's own performance and still poorer information about others. It does not explain all motivational effects or why excessive certainty arises. The authors describe their experiment as illustrative, with generalisation requiring further evidence.[1]

See also

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Don A. Moore and Paul J. Healy, “The Trouble With Overconfidence”, Psychological Review 115(2), 2008, pp. 502–517; published paper, especially pp. 502–506, 508–512 and 514.