Mihail Pojarsky/freedom of speech
Dima Khomak recently wrote an article[1] about freedom of speech that suddenly attracted a flurry of discussion. Alas, for some reason, many people read the text with their asses—how else can we explain their reading it as an attack on freedom of speech? In fact, Khomak stated the textbook libertarian position, straight from the Bureau of Weights and Measures: freedom of speech means that the state does not persecute you for your words, while property owners (for example, the owners of social networks) can set rules of conduct on their own platforms, including bans.
No one since John Stuart Mill would have thought to argue with that position. No one in their right mind has claimed that all points of view are equally valuable and equally useful. The problem is that we cannot determine which point of view is better with the state's club, but we can through debate and reputation. Different opinions have different values in the market of ideas, determined in a decentralized way through the judgments of many different participants. Some ideas become more popular, while others are increasingly shunned. And if ideas such as "white supremacism" are treated as a pile of shit, that does not violate freedom of speech. Otherwise, how could we distinguish the good from the bad without decency and reputation? No one is obliged to provide a platform for people who stink.
Nevertheless, when it comes to social networks, this position is not entirely correct. Private versus state ownership is a false dichotomy. Economist Elinor Ostrom won a Nobel Prize for proving that, despite the "tragedy of the commons", a third type of property—the commons—can be effective and even indispensable in some situations. Commons include forests and bodies of water, rivers and underground springs, streets and roads: resources that everyone uses and that cannot be divided into "portions". And I never tire of repeating that social networks are commons rather than private territories. Yes, a private owner pays for the infrastructure (and makes money from it), but users create all the content—much as residents fill a city with life, although its roads may be built by the state or a private company. Moreover, social networks were originally promoted and presented as public platforms, so their rules should not be set unilaterally. Similarly, the owner of a cafe operating under a public offer, rather than as a closed club, has brought his property into the public sphere and can no longer act arbitrarily.
Keeping a white supremacist off private property is fine, but keeping him out of a public Hyde Park really is a violation of freedom of speech. Of course, people will have to give him a wide berth while holding their noses. But what can you do? That is precisely the price we pay for our freedom and yours...
Mihail Pojarsky 2020-11-22
- ↑ David Homak, about freedom patreon
