Russian invasion of Ukraine/US Aid to Ukraine: Difference between revisions
From Liberpedia
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
[[File:Us-aid-by-country-gdp.jpeg|thumb|right]] | [[File:Us-aid-by-country-gdp.jpeg|thumb|right]] | ||
[[File:Military-spending-budget-aid.jpg|thumb|right]] | [[File:Military-spending-budget-aid.jpg|thumb|right]] | ||
== 1994: “you give your nukes to russia, they’ll promise not to invade you. deal?” == | == 1994: “you give your nukes to russia, they’ll promise not to invade you. deal?” == | ||
| Line 42: | Line 33: | ||
== 2022-2023 == | == 2022-2023 == | ||
* [https://cepa.org/article/its-costing-peanuts-for-the-us-to-defeat-russia/ It’s Costing Peanuts for the US to Defeat Russia] | |||
* [[David Wiley]], “[https://www.learnliberty.org/blog/libertarian-alternatives-to-war-with-russia/ Libertarian alternatives to war with Russia]” | |||
* [https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/three-four-americans-say-us-should-support-ukraine-despite-russian-threats-2022-10-05/ Three in four Americans say U.S. should support Ukraine despite Russian threats, Reuters/Ipsos poll shows] | |||
* [https://www.csis.org/analysis/united-states-running-out-weapons-send-ukraine Is the United States Running out of Weapons to Send to Ukraine?] | |||
* [https://www.hudson.org/foreign-policy/ten-myths-us-aid-ukraine-luke-coffey Ten Myths about US Aid to Ukraine] | |||
* [[Randy Mott]], “[https://twitter.com/randymot4/status/1633035945007104000 There is a major misconception the US is providing a big majority of the aid to UKR. This is only true of mil aid & because only the US had unused stores of the necessary eqpt. ]”, March 7, 2023 ([https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1633035945007104000.html thread]) ([https://liberpedia.net/threads/Randy-Mott-US-Aid-Ukraine.pdf pdf]) | |||
* [https://twitter.com/RonNehring/status/1619029784230764544 US military aid to Ukraine so far: $27.5 billion. This is just 3.2% of our 2023 defense budget. With these weapons, Ukraine is rapidly degrading Russia’s military capacity, which will take many years to restore, if ever.] | |||
== Objections and counter-arguments == | == Objections and counter-arguments == | ||
Revision as of 04:30, 20 March 2023
1994: “you give your nukes to russia, they’ll promise not to invade you. deal?”
2005: arms destruction
2014-2017: non-lethal aid
- Ukraine president secures U.S. military aid but not weapons, September 18, 2014
- Poroshenko asks Obama for weapons, obtains blankets, September 19, 2014
- Fact-checking Trump’s claim that Obama gave Ukraine ‘pillows and sheets’ (fact-check: true)
- “U.S. hands over armored military vehicles to Ukraine”, March 25, 2015 “The U.S. aid for Ukraine’s army will include 30 heavily armored Humvees and 200 other regular Humvees, as well as small drones, radios, counter-mortar radars and other equipment. All of the aid is nonlethal, and the drones are not armed.”
2017-2021
2022-2023
- Randy Mott, “There is a major misconception the US is providing a big majority of the aid to UKR. This is only true of mil aid & because only the US had unused stores of the necessary eqpt. ”, March 7, 2023 (thread) (pdf)
Objections and counter-arguments
- Sending Fighter Jets To Ukraine Raises The Specter Of The Cold War “The proposed arms shipments are significantly less provocative than the Soviets killing Americans in North Korea and Vietnam.” [1]
Benefits for the USA
- Timothy Snyder, “I have been hearing the idea from some Republicans that Ukrainian resistance comes at a cost to Americans. Nothing could be more wrong. Ukrainian resistance provides extraordinary security benefits to Americans” (thread) (pdf)
Opinion polls
Other countries’ aid
Estonia
More
- How successive U.S. administrations resisted arming Ukraine, March 5, 2022
- Seeks US Weapons at Middle East Arms Expo, February 24, 2014
- “U.S. Humvees Arrive In Ukraine”, March 26, 2015 “Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko welcomed the first 10 Humvees provided by the U.S. as part of non-lethal military aid. The vehicles were handed over to units which are fighting Russian-backed separatists in eastern Ukraine. It’s expected that a total of 230 Humvees will be delivered within the next 45 days.”
- Randy Mott, “A new theme is to force Ukraine to make peace. This is undoubtedly one of the dumbest ideas to emerge from the war. The Gaetz proposal would cut off US aid (now audited)to try to force a peace deal. This thread sets out the reasons why this is nonsense”, February 10, 2023 (thread) (pdf) (Matt Gaetz)
